The Bluegrass Ensemble

The bluegrass ensemble isn’t a term you’ll find being used much, if any. But I think it well describes what it is when you are talking about the various instruments used in a typical bluegrass band. If you’ve been playing or jamming for a while, you may already know how every instrument and voice fits in and makes for a distinctive sound. But for the sake of those new to the musical genre, here is a brief introduction on what comprises a typical bluegrass band, the roles of each instrument and what is going on between the instruments. 

Bass. We could say ‘This is an important instrument’ to each of the listed instruments here. But I think the bass is the most important of all, accepting the fact that there are at least one or two others involved (a bass by itself isn’t much on melodies, after all). Just like in a marching band with its bass drum beating out a rhythm for all others to follow, the upright bass, or bull fiddle as it is sometimes called, is responsible for keeping the rhythm, as well as keeping the chord progression for the entire band. The actual techniques of playing the bass aren’t as complicated as the other instruments, but the bass is afforded little room for mistakes in rhythm and proper chording. If the banjo player messes up, it may be that few if anyone notices, but let the bass flub-up, and everyone will turn around to look. Although bassists probably get in a good bit of experience in keys such as G, A, C and D, they should be able to navigate well in any key. The bass plays on the on beat. Interestingly, if you go to a bluegrass festival and start jamming, it is often the bass that is the most in demand instrument, not the ever-so-much-more-common banjo or guitar. It’s been my experience that most bassists also seem to be adept at at least one other instrument.

Guitar. If there is any one instrument that is considered indispensable, it is the guitar. It can hold a bass note, and so fill-in for an actual bass, it can play lead, and provide rhythm. Most singers hold forth behind a guitar, although fiddles and mandolins are frequently played by the lead singer in a band as well. You don’t see as many lead singers playing banjo, Dobro, or bass, but it is done. Most often you’ll see a guitar being used as a back-up instrument. A lot of guitarists can also take lead breaks in bluegrass, but not all of them. Guitars are effective at backing up in any key, playing the bass notes on beat and the strum on the off beat. For lead breaks, guitarists seem to prefer  C, D, E and G.

Fiddle. The most tradion-steeped of these bluegrass instruments, the fiddle is a violin, just named differently and setup slightly differently. For that matter,  nothing would stop a violinist from using an instrument setup as a violin from being used here. Fiddles are capable of playing extremely fast (as in Orange Blossom Special) and we even have a special category of old songs expressly meant to be played on the fiddle called (big surprise here…) fiddle tunes. We don’t normally think of the fiddle as a backup instrument, but it does an effective job of that, either by ‘chopping’ chord fragments, or by backup melody lines; they usually play backup chops on the off beat. Fiddlers seem to prefer keys of A and D.

Banjo. Banjos have the widest variety of styles that you’ll find among these instruments, from 2-finger to clawhammer to Scruggs, melodic and single-string,each with their own distinctive sound. Banjos themselves also vary widely and can be modified more than any of the others. Banjos display a considerable amount of syncopation, due to their unusual string configuration, as well as by how they are played, often emphasizing this hard-to-decipher cascade of notes. As with the guitar, banjos tend to play the bass notes on beat and the pinch (strum) on the off beat.

Mandolin. Mandolins are tuned just like the fiddle, GDAE. But since they are played with a pick rather than a bow, chords can be made with three or four courses of strings (a course is when you have identical strings tuned together in pairs; a mandolin has 8 strings in 4 courses instead of 4 strings alone like a fiddle). Mandolins usually supply backup in the form of a chop on the off beat.

Dobro. Perhaps the Dobro is more correctly called a resonator guitar. Gibson Guitar Company has acquired the rights to the name ‘Dobro’ as of 1993. The resonator guitar is simply a guitar that uses a metal cone for the resonator instead of the usual flat wood found on a regular guitar. It is usually played horizontally with a slide and three finger picks, employing much the same techniques as in modern three-finger banjo styles. Resonator guitars have a wonderful sustain, giving a very different effect from the usual brief sustain of banjos. Backing up is usually more along the lines of how a fiddle backs up, rather than how a banjo does it; with smooth and subtle melody or harmony lines during lulls in the singing or other instrumental breaks.

Posted in Banjos & Bluegrass, Beginning Banjo | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Being the Best in Your Zip Code

The last blog I wrote just now mentioned the fact that there will always be someone better than you at whatever you are doing. That’s indeed a bit humbling for some of us, I’ll agree. But still, we have to face it: none of us will ever be the very best of anything in the world; certainly not when it comes to things like playing the banjo, mandolin or guitar.

Perhaps we could be the best in the world at such specific things as raising our own children. After all, I have a cute little Grammy award from my oldest daughter that plainly states “World’s Greatest Dad!” – proof positive!

But about those banjos. How about a more realistic goal? It seems quite do-able to strive to be the best in your own zip code! Unless your zip code starts with 372, in which case you live in Nashville and have some pretty hefty competition. I kind of assume that Nashville has the largest number of banjo players and perhaps the highest concentration of them as well.

As an aside – if it’s true that Nashville has the most banjo players, then I wonder which place has the second highest number or concentration – maybe somewhere in North Carolina or Virginia?

Posted in Beginning Banjo | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Why Play the Banjo?

Why indeed! I can think of several reasons…

You get to meet some of the craz… er, nicest people around!
OK, if crazy is what you’re looking for then, yes you can find that, too! As with anything in life, communication is the key. Find a new friend or two and start making music.

It’s just plain fun!
And what justification do we need for good clean fun? None, I hope. Dale Carnegie once said: “People rarely succeed unless they have fun in what they are doing” which leads us into reason number 3…

The sense of satisfaction you get from having succeeded with your musical goals
The satisfaction of a job well-done. Regardless of the task before you, if you’ve lived very long, you know the rewards that await you when, as the saying goes ‘practice makes perfect’! Imagine yourself playing that perfect banjo break – it’s quite possible, you know.

It’s relaxing
If you’ve ever thought of sitting on a front porch in a rocking chair and picking a banjo, then you’ll understand what I mean.

“Music has charms to soothe the savage beast, to soften rocks, or bend a knotted oak. ”
William Congreve

It puts you in touch with your creative processes
And we all know what side benefits the creative process bestows upon whatever else we are doing (work, for instance).

“Creativity involves breaking out of established patterns in order to look at things in a different way. ”
Edward De Bono

“The essential part of creativity is not being afraid to fail.”
Edwin H. Land

“True creativity often starts where language ends.”
Arthur Koestler

It’s America’s Instrument!
Even though we have good evidence of banjos with drone strings being brought over or created by slaves from Africa in the 1700s and 1800s, the 5-string banjo as we know it today is vastly different from it’s African ancestor. With it’s tone ring, resonator, drum head, metal strings, frets, etc., truly, it is an American invention!

It’s the hot-rod of musical instruments
By that I mean that it is the most easily modified of musical instruments. Did you know you can take a banjo apart; take the neck off; replace the drum head and tone ring; adjust the neck to set the string action, and so much more. You can really tweak it to get just the sound you like, from a deep mellow voice, to a bright, clear ringing! That’s a lot of the reason why an experienced player can hear a recording and make an excellent guess as to who (among famous players, at least) is playing!

It’s the most genuine, folksy and content musical instrument I know of
That’s about as good a compliment as I can give to a piece of wood and metal. Perhaps that’s why Charles Schultz portrayed the banjo in just such a light on several occasions in his Peanuts comic strip.

You can develop your own style
Be as individualistic as you please; banjos go so far beyond their stereotype. There are lots of folks out there picking, frailing and clawhammering on banjos. They’re making Irish folk melodies, Bach (Bach is a natural for the banjo, by the way), old-time, 1960’s protest songs, Jazz (Dixieland as well as more avant-garde)… Even within Bluegrass, you have Scruggs style, Melodic, Reno… so many styles, so little time.

You can connect to your roots
Bluegrass is especially an authentic, back-home way of thinking. It places high value on grass-roots things that are real, honest and clean.

Posted in Banjos and Society, Beginning Banjo | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Introducing Two-Finger Style Banjo

I love exploring different styles of playing the banjo. Although I’m mostly a modern three-finger style player, I do know a smattering of other styles. I realize I’ve not blogged on another style I’ve recently started playing: two-finger style.

I was introduced to this very interesting style by a friend and student, Jim Goins. Jim learned this as his primary playing style from Mac McCleese in Talladega, Alabama. Also influential on Jim’s playing has been Ed Teague from Georgia, who I’ve mentioned here before.

It is a great style for getting a certain sound that far from modern bluegrass. It’s a slow, calm, nostalgic feel, as I see it; more so than even clawhammer, even though clawhammer style seems to be a bit more flexible than two-finger style. Two finger style is like neither modern three-finger with picks, nor like clawhammer. And yet, it has similarities to each. Let me explain.

Two finger style uses just the right hand thumb and index finger, with no picks. The thumb almost always stays just on the 5th string (the only exception is if you are using the drop thumb technique, similar to drop thumb in clawhammer style). The index finger picks up, as in three finger style, yet without a pick. So the picking process is this:

1 – Pick up with the index finger on any of strings 1 through 4.
2 – Brush down with the index finger
3 – Pick down with the thumb on the 5th string.

Typically there is a rest between steps 1 and 2, with no pause between steps 2 and 3.

After talking with Mac McCleese, he recommends these steps in the following sequence:

1 – Pick down with the thumb on the 5th string.
2 – Pick up with the index finger on any of strings 1 through 4.
3 – Brush down with the index finger as needed.

Of course to get a certain melody either way, you’ll have to vary this a bit, maybe picking two or three times before a brush, or some other such variation, depending on the song at hand. Occasionally, you may want or need to drop thumb, where you bring the thumb down from the 5th string to pick one of the other strings; either for a series of thumb picks, or else alternating notes with the index finger.

Now I have heard some old-time players who simply do this; thumb on the 5th string and index for a simple melody. But as you see, this two-finger styles adds a down-stroke brush; an interesting element borrowed directly from clawhammer style . The first time I saw Jim play this, I had to do a double and triple-take; then, I had to get him to slow it way down so I could see that brush. When compared to the more usual clawhammer brush, the brush in this style is almost invisible unless you really get close in to inspect it, and thus gives it a bit of a mysterious feel to it. A “how is he doing that?” sort of an effect. Much like the first few times you see someone play modern bluegrass style banjo and wonder what on earth is going on.

So that’s it! Two-finger style is relatively easy. It doesn’t take volumes to explain, so all that’s left is to go practice it some!

BTW, my very first exposure to two-finger style banjo playing was many years ago. I recall hearing a recording of Aunt Bertha Robinson play “Big Jim” back in the 1970s. She was a well-known banjo player who played in the two-finger style. This song was on a vinyl record put out by the local Huntsville Association of Folk Musicians (HAFM), now called the Huntsville Traditional Music Association at http://www.huntsvillefolk.org/.

Give this intriguing style a try. It has a distinct, graceful, slow sound that’s different from both modern three-finger and from clawhammer.

Posted in 2-Finger Style, Banjos and Society | Tagged , , , , , , , | 10 Comments

Quitting While You're Behind

Imagine you are going to a regional bluegrass festival (That would the the Tennessee Valley Old-Time Fiddlers Convention in Athens, Alabama for me). You hear some young banjo player picking out an incredible set of licks and you think to yourself “Man! I’ll never be that good!”

To put it confusingly: most of us have some experience with this, which is more than any of us would like.

Actually, I don’t think that way much at all, but on those rare occasions I just tell myself that there are two ways to approach that feeling.

1 – You can go ahead and think you’ll never be that good and let it deflate you; you stop playing for a while until you can get a new, better attitude.

-OR-

2 – You can be inspired by what you have seen someone else do.

Remember that there is always going to be someone better than you at whatever the task at hand. At banjo playing, at folding the laundry… at just about everything! Perhaps it’s just a tinge of old-fashioned jealousy, but the sooner you can get over it, the better for your continued advancement. Like anger, such feeling can eat you up inside if you let them.

Also realize that you may be feeling this way because you yourself are getting better. So much so, that you now recognise exactly what the other guy is doing; you know enough about it to realize that this is something terrific going on, and you would also like to be playing it. Give yourself credit here for what you bring to the moment as an active listener. Realize that you are a lot closer to being able to play the same licks than you think.

If you are thinking of putting off practice – for a day, for a year – I hope this helps you see things as not so bad. Keep persevering and don’t give up!

Posted in Beginning Banjo, Music in General, Tips & Techniques | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Increasing Speed with Single String Style

Since returning from NashCamp a few weeks ago, I’ve been more diligent with two things. One, I’ve been more structured in my practice, allotting about one third of my time to each of three categories: playing songs I already know, learning new material and techniques and working on trouble spots and other such things that require greater than usual detail.

Secondly, I’ve been practicing single string style more. That’s because I’ve been more inspired by it since getting one especially helpful tip from Bill Evans while at NashCamp; be sure to adjust you right hand up and down as you move from string to string. That, along with picking a bit more lightly, has made a surprising difference in the clarity and quality of my single string playing. By keeping your exact same hand position in relation to each string, you’ll have much better control and minimize mistakes such as accidentally picking the adjacent string.

With this new technique, I’ve been able to increase my speed on single string licks by roughly 20%. That’s a pretty big leap! And a quick one as well.

As a related item, I see this also works with certain more difficult melodic techniques that have been giving me consistent problems in times past. For instance, one tune I like to play is ‘Orange Blossom Special’ a la Carl Jackson. Part of the chorus, though, has always been tough to pull of at greater speeds. Using this movement of the right hand as the strings change underneath has helped increase my speed on this as well. I see here that it’s the same issue as with increasing speed with single string.

Thanks for the helpful hint, Bill!

Posted in Reno & Single-String Style, Tips & Techniques | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Found: An Old Stella Harmony 12-String Guitar

I was cleaning out the attic today and noticed something: a 12-string guitar. Sure, I’d seen it there before – it used to belong to my oldest brother Mike (the same brother who had that first banjo I would strum on as a young child). Today, though, I saw it with the possibility of fixing it up. It was awfully dusty and had six strings on it, which looked to be too heavy a gauge. The frets were also in need of some rounding off, as playing it was difficult due to their being so squared up. (Later, Mike told me that the frets had been filed down and hadn’t been rounded off afterwards.)

I got this old 12-string Harmony Stella out of the attic, dusted and cleaned it up, did a little fret work on it and put on some light gauge D’Addario EJ38 strings.

Now it sounds very nice; better than I ever thought it would. It also plays well; just a little more than the usual neck bow, so the neck hasn’t been overly warped down through the years. It looks pretty decent as well with its classic sunburst pattern. But then, it’s a rather old American-made instrument from the early 60s or so –good quality, even though it was an entry-level guitar back then.

My brother must have practiced on this guitar extensively, as there are noticeably deep rub marks on the neck from making G, C and D chords; the D chord was made with the thumb over the top, I can tell. Also, I’ve never seen this on a fretboard before, but if you sight down the neck in good light, you can see small indentations between the frets where fingers rubbed against the fretboard. This guitar has been played a lot. In this photo, you can also see a large worn area on the body just below where the neck joins the body.

Well, I had to go google ’12-string Stella Harmony guitar’, and yes, they have a great reputation! These guitars were made from solid wood and were perhaps the best quality instruments that Harmony made under the Stella label. This was the same type guitar that Blind Willie McTell used for his 1956 last sessions.

I’m glad to have this quality vintage guitar back amongst my other instruments now.

Posted in Guitars | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

The Purpose of Reading Music

By and large, banjoists nowadays use tablature rather than musical notation in order to convey what’s going on on the fretboard. This hasn’t always been the case, but since the advent of bluegrass, and the inclusion of the banjo into the fold of instruments used in this musical genre, we have grown accustomed to seeing not only banjo, but also mandolin, guitar, etc. tablature as the standard means by which we communicate musical ideas in bluegrass.

But this is a different thought process from actually reading music. Whenever I hear the question “Can you read music?” I usually think instead of questions like “Can you read music for the banjo?”or “Can you read music for the piano?”. I think this is the more appropriate question and here’s why.

People don’t usually learn tablature to the point of being able to sight read it as someone would with standard musical notation. Although I have seen some folks who can indeed assimilate tab very quickly. I just use tab to the extent that I can either get it memorized by rote (which is good material for later improvisation), or else just enough to get the idea and then adapt it to my own existing left and right hand techniques. Reading music in standard notation, on the other hand (no pun intended), involves a two-step process of learning:
1 – Instantly identify the notes in sheet music.
2 – Instantly place the correct finger at the correct fret and string to make this note.

Eventually, we get to the place where we no longer think about this as a two-step process. Our hands have learned it and we instantly place our fingers when we see the notes on the staff. At this point we can say we have learned to read music for that particular instrument. In addition, we are also half way there with learning to read music for another instrument; we already have part one accomplished.

We bluegrass musicians know well the advantages of tablature. The main one I’m thinking of right now being that we don’t have to think of just which D above middle C we need to fret, for instance. There is only one choice in tablature, unlike standard notation, which simply gives you the note – you figure out how to fret it yourself in standard notation.

But it’s that very deficiency, if you will, that allows us to be able to sigh-read music much more easily than with tablature. That is, to be able to take a piece of music and instantly start playing it (after the mandatory training to get there, of course). For stringed instruments, where we have a choice of where to fret to make most individual notes, notation doesn’t pretend to say how you produce that note; it just tells you which note to produce. As we learn the basics of sight reading on our instrument, say, on the mandolin, we make the assumption of using only the first 7 frets. This constraint allows us to learn to sight read more easily than if the constrain were not there. Tab doesn’t have that constrain there (use only the first 7 frets, for instance) and so that freedom makes it harder to sight read with. Someone could come along and learn to sigh read tablature, perhaps, but by it’s very nature it doesn’t lend itself to instant production like standard notation.

Posted in Philosophical Ramblings | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Banjo Chords in D Tuning

5-string bluegrass banjo players definitely prefer open G tuning to all other tunings. That said, there are a large number of possible tunings, each evoking a different mood in the listener; sometimes subtle or mysterious, other times harsh or exciting. D tuning, such as used by Earl Scruggs in Reuben, is probably the second most common tuning. Earl does a masterful job of laying down the most compelling bluesy licks based out of D tuning when he plays Reuben.

One thing that is easily overlooked when playing a lead to something like Reuben, is the use of chords to back up. One option I’ve heard is to muffle the banjo strings and just plunk out a rhythm. It sounds sort of like an old percolator-style coffee pot, and the chords aren’t relevant so it’s pretty simple.

The other day, some of us were going over John Hartford’s ‘Gentle on My Mind’, made famous by Glen Campbell back in the 70s. If I recall correctly, this was even his theme song for The Glen Campbell Show back then. This uses a banjo in D tuning for some very nice backup. By it’s very presence with some great chords, it’s almost as though the banjo is playing a lead break in this song, just a little quieter.

So this was a good time for me to work out some basic chords for the banjo in D tuning. I’ve not seen these elsewhere before, and I hope I got them without any errors. Anyway, here are some basic chords for the 5-string banjo in D tuning (aDF#AD). What each diagram shows in simply where to place each finger of the left hand, beginning with the 5th string.

D
0 0 0 0 0 (ie, open. Good ‘ol bar chords)

D (2nd inversion)
0 4 3 5 4
If you’re familiar with 7th chords in open G, then you’ll immediately recognize this hand position as being a 7th if you were in G tuning. Here, it is a D major.

D7
0 0 0 3 0
This one is interesting – note how you can make 6ths and 7ths from this bar chord, just like in open G tuning – except it is done on string number 2, instead of string 1. To make a 6th, just move that 2nd string from the 3rd fret to the 2nd fret.

G
x 0 1 2 0
Almost a D7 if it were in G tuning, but not quite – don’t forget to flip those fingers,though!

G (2nd inversion)
x 5 5 5 5 (ie, a bar chord)

G (3rd inversion)
x 9 8 10 9
Just like the 2nd inversion of D above, but 5 frets up.

A
0 2 3 4 2
Now this hand position is certainly new! I like to do it as a bar chord with two extra fingers for strings 2 & 3. That might change as time goes on, though. This also does well as a partial, suitable for three finger rolls as:
0 2 3 4 x

A (2nd inversion)
0 7 7 7 7
Just moving up the neck…

Am
0 2 3 3 2
A useful minor chord hand position. Again, I like to make this as a bar chord, plus two fingers for strings 2 & 3.
Also try:
0 0 3 3 2

B
x 4 5 6 4
Movin’ on up…

Bm
x 4 5 5 4
Just two up from A minor. Now find C minor if you can.

You may have noticed three hand positions for the major chords here; yes, there is that pattern, just as in open G tuning. Fascinating!

I hope this gives you enough material to allow you to tackle some improvised breaks in some otherwise though keys, such as D, E and F. Combine this with some Scruggs tuners, and you’ll be capable of these keys easily; that’s a lot of bang for the buck!

Also check out Brians Huge Chordlist at http://chordlist.brian-amberg.de/en/five-stringed/d/ for lots more chords in different keys, for all kinds of instruments!

Posted in Tips & Techniques | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

A Taxonomy of Sloppy Playing

Sloppy playing can creep up on you before you know it, especially if you’re just starting out learning to play the banjo. As time goes on and you get more experience, you’ll start to recognize when you’re getting sloppy with your playing. And if you’re sloppy with your playing, then most likely it’s because you’ve been sloppy with your practice.

Here is a brief taxonomy of sloppy playing. Most of these really are self-explanatory, and the solutions are all pretty much the same; perfect practice makes perfect! Perhaps listing them this way will help increase awareness of the specific mechanism behind the sloppiness we occasionally find in our playing.

Can you think of other items that would go on this list of sloppy playing habits?

  1. Left Hand Problems
       Poor fretting
       Poor slides, hammer-ons and pull-offs
       Pull-off occurring when not needed
  2. Right Hand Problems
       Hit wrong string
       Hit multiple strings
       Hit didn’t get across string
       Too loud or too soft
       Wrong emphasis
       Wrong rhythm
       Not planting either ring or little fingers on the drumhead
  3. Sync Problems
       Left-Right hand sync
       Syncing with other instruments
  4. Other:
       Out of Tune
       Doing just enough effort to get by
Posted in Beginning Banjo, Tips & Techniques | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments